2003 -- H 5829

=======

LC01718

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2003

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO HEALTH AND SAFETY - ELECTRONIC WASTE PRODUCER

RESPONSIBILITY

     Introduced By: Representatives Naughton, Giannini, Ginaitt, Kennedy, and Lewiss

     Date Introduced: February 11, 2003

     Referred To: House Health, Education & Welfare

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Title 23 of the General Laws entitled "Health and Safety" is hereby

1-2

amended by adding thereto the following chapter:

1-3

     CHAPTER 24.10

1-4

ELECTRONIC WASTE PRODUCER RESPONSIBILITY ACT

1-5

     23-24.10-1. Short title. - - This chapter shall be known as the “Electronic Waste

1-6

Producer Responsibility Act.”

1-7

     23-24.10-2. Findings. - - The general assembly has found and hereby declares that:

1-8

     (1) Electronic waste contains lead, mercury, chromium, cadmium, polyvinyl chloride,

1-9

mixed plastics, beryllium, brominated flame retardants and other hazardous substances, and

1-10

therefore pose a threat to human health and the environment if improperly disposed of at the end

1-11

of their useful life;

1-12

     (2) Less than ten (10) percent of discarded electronic equipment are currently recycled,

1-13

with the remainder stockpiled or improperly disposed of, while large quantities of the toxic

1-14

equipment intended for recycling are shipped overseas for dismantling under horrific conditions

1-15

and many domestic processors can not attest to the ultimate disposition of the materials collected;

1-16

     (3) The full extent of the public health threat and environmental contamination resulting

1-17

from electronic equipment entering the waste stream through disposal into landfills or

1-18

incinerators is unknown, but is estimated that forty percent (40%) of the heavy metals in

2-1

municipal landfills come from electronic discards;

2-2

     (4) Currently, producers of electronic equipment bear none of the burden or responsibility

2-3

for safely managing discarded electronic equipment at the end of its useful life, burdening state

2-4

taxpayers, local governments and end users with these costs and responsibilities;

2-5

     (5) The intent of this chapter is to shift the financial responsibility for the collection and

2-6

recycling of discarded electronic waste from the taxpayers of Rhode Island to the producers of

2-7

electronic products.

2-8

     23-24.10-3. Definitions. - - For the purpose of this chapter:

2-9

     (1) “Department” means the department of environmental management.

2-10

     (2) “Electronic equipment” means equipment that: is dependent on electric currents

2-11

electromagnetic fields in order to work properly and contains one or more printed circuit boards;

2-12

and includes, but is not limited to, computer equipment such as cathode ray tubes, display

2-13

monitors, central processing units, keyboards, printers, computer peripherals; display monitors,

2-14

and displays; telecommunication equipment such as telephones, cellular phones, facsimile

2-15

machines, answering machines; small electronic devices and appliances containing one or more

2-16

circuit boards; video and stereo equipment; televisions, toys, games and educational devices

2-17

containing one or more printed circuit boards; and major household appliances containing one or

2-18

more printed circuit boards.

2-19

     (3) “Electronic waste” means electronic equipment which has been discarded, become

2-20

obsolete, ceased to function, is no longer wanted by its owner, or for any other reason enters the

2-21

collection, recovery, treatment, processing or recycling system.

2-22

     (4) “Environment” includes, but is not limited to, all the state’s natural resources

2-23

including land, air and water resources, and plant and animal species, and the habitat upon which

2-24

they depend.

2-25

     (5) “Historic waste” means electronic equipment which became electronic waste prior to

2-26

the effective date of the requirements of this act, the producer of which is still in business.

2-27

     (6) “Orphan waste” means electronic waste manufactured by or bearing the brand name

2-28

of a company which is no longer in business as of the effective date of this act.

2-29

     (7) “Plan” means the plan for producer financed collection, recovery, and recycling of

2-30

electronic waste as provided for in section 23-24.10-5.

2-31

     (8) “Producer” means any person irrespective of the sales techniques or channels used to

2-32

sell their products, including means of distance communication, that manufactures and sells

2-33

electronic equipment under its own brand; resells under its own brand equipment produced by

2-34

other suppliers, a reseller not being regarded as the producer if the brand of the actual

3-1

manufacturer appears on the equipment; imports electronic equipment for first sale in Rhode

3-2

Island.

3-3

     (9) “Recycling” means the reprocessing of the waste materials for the original purpose or

3-4

for other purposes, but excluding energy recovery or energy generation by means of combusting

3-5

electronic waste with or without other waste.

3-6

     (10) “Re-use” means any operation by which electronic waste or components thereof are

3-7

used for the same purpose for which they were conceived, including the continued use of the

3-8

equipment or components thereof which are returned to collection points, recyclers, or producers.

3-9

     23-24.10-4. Financial responsibility. - - (a) No later then twenty-four (24) months

3-10

following the effective date of this chapter producers shall be responsible for implementing a

3-11

program for financing the environmentally-sound collection, treatment, recovery, and final

3-12

disposition of discarded and obsolete electronic equipment, including orphan and historic waste.

3-13

     (b) Producers are responsible for financing the environmentally sound management of the

3-14

waste from its own products, but may execute this obligation through individual financing

3-15

schemes or in cooperation with other producers.

3-16

     (c) Consumers and equipment end users may be responsible for delivering electronic

3-17

waste into the collection system, as may be provided for in the producer’s plan; provided,

3-18

however, that producers may include direct collection, reverse delivery systems, or reverse

3-19

logistics systems in their plan.

3-20

     (d) Consumers shall not be charged to return electronic waste.

3-21

     (e) Producers failing to implement financial responsibility program within the time

3-22

provided for in this chapter shall be prohibited from selling their products in Rhode Island.

3-23

     23-24.10-5. Financial responsibility plan. - - (a) No later than six (6) months following

3-24

the effective date of this act, producers of electronic equipment sold in Rhode Island shall submit

3-25

to the department for review a plan designed to meet their responsibilities under this act.

3-26

     (b) Said plan may not be approved by the department unless the plan, at a minimum,

3-27

provides:

3-28

     (1) An effective system for financing the collection, treatment, recovery, re-use, and

3-29

disposition of all products sold by the producer in Rhode Island; and

3-30

     (2) A plan for financing that producer’s share of orphan and historic waste in Rhode

3-31

Island, as determined by the department, as of the effective date of their financial obligation; and

3-32

     (3) A plan for complying with the labeling, consumer notification, and public education

3-33

requirements of this chapter that are necessary to ensure the protection of electronics users,

3-34

processors and recyclers, and ensure participation in the producer’s plan; and

4-1

     (4) Documentation of the willingness of all necessary parties involved to implement the

4-2

proposed plan, and assurances that the plan will comply with all applicable state and local

4-3

environmental laws and regulations; and

4-4

     (5) A description of the performance measurers to be used and reported by the producer

4-5

to the department to demonstrate that the collection system is meeting measurers of the program’s

4-6

effectiveness required by the department; and

4-7

     (6) A description of the alternative or additional actions that will be implemented by the

4-8

producer to improve the collection, recovery and recycling systems in the event that the program

4-9

targets are not met.

4-10

     (d) The department shall assess a fee on each producer which shall cover the full costs

4-11

incurred by the department for the review of proposed plans and for other costs incurred by the

4-12

department for implementation of this chapter.

4-13

     (e) Upon a determination by the department that a producer is not meeting the

4-14

performance standards set by the department for the collection and recycling of electronic waste,

4-15

the department may order said producer to take actions the department deems necessary to

4-16

achieve said performance standards.

4-17

     (f) Any producer who fails to meet any of the requirements of this section within the time

4-18

required shall be prohibited from selling electronic equipment in Rhode Island.

4-19

     23-24.10-6. Disposal ban. - - Electronic waste regulated pursuant to this act, including

4-20

the constituent sub-units and/or materials from which the waste is composed of, shall not be

4-21

disposed of in landfills, incinerators, cement kilns or other forms of energy recovery or energy

4-22

generation dependent on combustion.

4-23

     23-24.10-7. Hazardous materials phase out. - - (a) No later than twelve (12) months

4-24

following the effective date of this act, producers selling electronic equipment in Rhode Island

4-25

must phase out the use of lead, mercury, cadmium, hexavalent chromium, brominated flame

4-26

retardants, and polyvinyl chloride and only offer for sale products that contain less harmful

4-27

alternatives.

4-28

     (b) If a producer provides sufficient demonstration to the department that it is technically

4-29

impossible to use an alternative substance, a limited term exemption may be issued by the

4-30

department. An exemption shall be rescinded by the department when the department determines

4-31

that a less harmful alternative for the substance can be used.

4-32

     (c) If the exemption is granted by the department, the department may assign a limited

4-33

amount of time before the exemption expires to ensure that producers are investing in research

4-34

and development to identify an appropriate less harmful alternative.

5-1

     23-24.10-8. Labeling requirement. - - (a) No later than twelve (12) months following

5-2

the effective date of this act, electronic equipment sold in Rhode Island must be clearly marked

5-3

and/or labeled, or informational materials shall be provided with the new product, which provide

5-4

consumers and end users with information relating to the following:

5-5

     (1) the hazardous materials contained in the electronic equipment and the parts or sub-

5-6

units which contain the particular substances;

5-7

     (2) the requirements not to dispose of electronic equipment in landfills, incinerators or

5-8

any other means not approved as part of the producer’s plan; and

5-9

     (3) a toll-free phone number and internet web site address where consumers can obtain

5-10

information and instructions about the safe collection of the electronic product through the

5-11

producer’s plan.

5-12

     (4) as part of an approved program plan, a producer shall implement a consumer

5-13

education plan that will provide consumers with an information about:

5-14

     (i) the prohibition on disposal of electronic waste by any means not included as part of

5-15

the producer’s approved program plan;

5-16

     (ii) the electronic waste return and collection systems available to them;

5-17

     (iii) the potential effects on the environment and human health as a result of the presence

5-18

of hazardous substances contained in electronic equipment and the dangers of improper disposal;

5-19

and

5-20

     (iv) the consumers’ and electronic equipment users’ roles in contributing to the re-use,

5-21

recycling, and other forms of electronic waste recovery.

5-22

     (b) No later than twenty-four (24) months following implementation of the producer’s

5-23

plan, each producer must demonstrate to the department that it has achieved a level of eighty-five

5-24

(85%) percent public awareness of the program for each of its covered product categories through

5-25

independent public polling. Producers may collectively undertake such a demonstration of public

5-26

awareness so long as the polling instrument is designed to identify public awareness of a majority

5-27

of producers’ programs or a majority of the electronic equipment types covered by this act. The

5-28

design, protocols and implementation plan for the opinion polling required in this section must be

5-29

approved by the department.

5-30

     (c) As part of an approved plan, to facilitate the correct and environmentally sound

5-31

treatment of electronic waste, producers must demonstrate to the department that they have

5-32

adequate measurers to provide information to recyclers and processors for their electronic

5-33

equipment. No later than twelve (12) months after new electronic equipment enters the market,

5-34

producers shall provide new information to recyclers and processors regarding the end of life

6-1

treatment of the new product relating to disassembly, material content, and safety concerns.

6-2

     23-24.10-9. Worker health and safety. – All persons collecting, recovering, and

6-3

recycling electronic waste as part of an approved plan must protect the health and safety of their

6-4

workers and contractors by:

6-5

     (a) providing clear evidence to the department of compliance with all state and federal

6-6

occupational safety and health laws and regulations; and

6-7

     (b) performing routine industrial hygiene monitoring and quarterly reporting for all

6-8

facilities for all hazardous materials of concern, including, but not limited to, monitoring for

6-9

airborne lead and bromine, chlorine, and mercury compounds; and

6-10

     (c) performing routine human health monitoring and quarterly reporting in accordance

6-11

with all applicable privacy protections for all workers and contractors, including, but not limited

6-12

to, blood testing for exposure to lead and bromine, chlorine, and mercury compounds.

6-13

     23-24.10-10. Prison labor. - - No plan may include reliance on prison labor unless all

6-14

incarcerated workers involved in the processing and recycling of electronic waste are provided

6-15

with compensation equivalent to market rate wages for the work performed and are afforded the

6-16

protections of federal and state occupational safety and health laws and regulations, as well as the

6-17

additional worker safety and health protections required by this act.

6-18

     23-24.10-11. Export ban. - - No person who collects, recovers, treats, processes, or

6-19

recycles electronic waste shall export said waste to any country where the export of hazardous

6-20

waste is prohibited by the Basel Ban Amendment decision (Decision III/1) of the Basel

6-21

Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movement of Hazardous Waste and Their Disposal.

6-22

All producers shall provide no later than January 1, each year to the department written

6-23

documentation, in a form and manner determined by the department, that their program has not

6-24

resulted in the overseas export of electronic waste to any country prohibited by this section.

6-25

     23-24.10-12. State procurement. - - Notwithstanding other policies or guidelines for the

6-26

procurement of equipment, supplies and other products, no later than six (6) months following the

6-27

effective date of this chapter the Rhode Island department of administration shall establish

6-28

purchasing and procurement policies requiring vendors of electronic equipment sold to the state

6-29

to take back electronic waste when the equipment becomes obsolete, is discarded or is otherwise

6-30

taken out of service. The Rhode Island department of administration shall also establish a

6-31

preference for electronic equipment that meets the environmental performance standards

6-32

established pursuant to this chapter relating to the reduction or elimination of hazardous

6-33

materials.

6-34

     23-24.10-13. Compliance. - - (a) Plans required pursuant to this chapter shall be

7-1

submitted to, reviewed by, and approved or disapproved by the department. Plans shall be

7-2

evaluated based upon their sufficiency in light of all the required elements and the department

7-3

shall develop a means for scoring initial submission and providing feedback to producers for

7-4

integration into their final plans.

7-5

     (b) Reports detailing performance of the producer’s financial responsibility program and

7-6

detailing compliance with all the requirements set forth above must be submitted no later than

7-7

January 1, each year to the department. All such reports shall be reviewed within six (6) months

7-8

of their submission and notices of deficiency or noncompliance provided by the department to

7-9

producers by the end of the following quarter.

7-10

     (c) Annual reports required under this section and all other reports outlining the results of

7-11

producer’s program for the current year and two (2) prior years must be made available to the

7-12

general public through the internet and on request.

7-13

     23-24.10-14. Private right of enforcement. - - Each person has the right to a healthful

7-14

environment and protection from contamination resulting from disposal of electronic waste. Any

7-15

person may enforce this right, as well as enforce the provisions and requirements of this act,

7-16

against any party, government or private, through appropriate legal proceedings, including

7-17

declaratory and equitable relief, civil penalties, and restoration damages, to protect the public

7-18

health and environment of Rhode Island from pollution, impairment or destruction resulting from

7-19

electronic waste. The court may award the full costs of litigation, including, but not limited to,

7-20

reasonable expert witness and attorneys’ fees, to the plaintiffs should they prevail. This provision

7-21

is supplementary to existing rights and procedures provided by law.

7-22

     23-24.10-15. Regulations. - - The department shall promulgate rules and regulations as

7-23

may be necessary to implement and carry out the provisions of this chapter.

7-24

     23-24.10-16. Severability and construction. – The provisions of this chapter shall be

7-25

severable, and if any court declares any phrase, clause, sentence, or provision of this chapter to be

7-26

invalid, or its applicability of any government, agency, person, or circumstance is declared

7-27

invalid, the remainder of the chapter and its relevant applicability shall not be affected. The

7-28

provisions of this chapter shall be liberally construed to give effect to the purposes thereof.

7-29

     SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01718

=======

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO HEALTH AND SAFETY - ELECTRONIC WASTE PRODUCER

RESPONSIBILITY

***

8-1

     This act would create the electronic waste producer responsibility act designed to regulate

8-2

the disposal of electronic waste.

8-3

     This act would take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01718

=======